00:00
00:00
00:01
Transcript
1/0
All right, so tonight we're gonna
return to... Mental illness issues, descriptions, prescriptions,
a biblical perspective on these things. We're pretty much wrapping
up the content of this book. It's not the only thing we're
talking about. I'm drawing heavily from it, though. So again, I'm
going to recommend it. It's Michael Imlett. He's a doctor. He's also got
an MDiv, and he's done counseling. So the medical information that
I'm getting is from either him or the stuff that he's citing.
And this is very helpful. I'm trying to give you the basic,
content of this book, which over these past three, this one included,
I guess, will be pretty much covering most of it, but obviously
it's gonna go into more depth. So if you want more on this kind
of stuff, that's the book to read. And I've got some others
that we're either gonna go into that or, I don't know, maybe
do some other topical thing, but that's gonna be the plan
for tonight and for the weeks going forward, the months going
forward. So we pretty much have talked about what these diagnoses
are, these mental health diagnoses are. We've talked about them,
how to think about them. I don't want to convey that mental health
diagnoses in the secular world or coming from the secular world
are never useful for the church. We wouldn't say that because
sometimes things like Asperger's, which is a kind of autism or
certain types of autism, things like that, once they've been
diagnosed, it will Maybe help us to recognize when somebody
has a weakness as opposed to a sin. So it'll distinguish between
them being unable and unwilling to do something that they should
be doing or would be a mark of maturity even. A difference between
can't and won't. So it's not a refusal. That is
to say there are some diagnoses that will help us understand
those kind of things, recognize those differences in someone.
We also want to recognize that those outside of the church that
have been dealing with these issues still have gathered a
lot of information and observations from various conditions. There's
experts in certain fields that will still have good content,
things like that. They don't necessarily always
have the right solutions, to what these problems are, and
they don't really have the ability to explain it as well in some
senses, but their observations can be useful. So they might
compile a list of like, with obsessive people, here are the
patterns of thinking that we tend to see in obsessive compulsive
people. And you could read those and
you'd be like, okay, I can see that, and it'll start to help you confront
a little bit of what somebody might be dealing with that's
obsessive. So, there are secular sources that have good observations
that still help us. It can likewise tell us when
somebody's been diagnosed, it might tell us when there is a
physical cause that's more at play, since some of these diagnoses
take testing and expertise to discover, and some of them have
these physical elements to them that obviously we're not going
to have the capability to do in the church. We might be able
to pick up on it, but we can't do any of that testing. We don't
have a blood lab behind the training room or anything. With all that
being said, with all that we've talked about with the diagnoses
stuff, we want to talk about the psychoactive medications. Understanding them and even asking
the questions of should they be used. Psychoactive medications. Those are also called psychotropic
or psychiatric medications. It's all the same thing, same
idea. These are chemical substances that are designed to enter the
brain tissue from the bloodstream and they cause changes in mood,
thoughts, emotions, and ultimately behavior. So that's what a psychoactive
or psychotropic or psychiatric medication is. And that's what
we're going to be talking about. Most medications will have a psychoactive
effect if you take them in high enough doses. So some blood pressure
pills, if you have too much of it, might cause drowsiness. You
might have difficulty concentrating. Those are symptoms of some of
these other mental health issues. That is a psychoactive effect,
ultimately. It changes your mood and your
thoughts and your brain function. Pain narcotics do this. You'll
get a sense of euphoria. I've had a lot of narcotics for
a lot of accidents and surgeries. It makes me really talkative.
It makes me overly affectionate. I think Andrea would testify,
too. She notices a change in my mood. my emotions and a little bit
of my behavior when I've had my pain medication. Now, obviously,
this has been years, but in the past. So in a high enough dose,
it's gonna change, it's gonna have a psychoactive effect, but
we're talking about the ones that have been designed for psychoactive
effects on the brain. So I'm gonna give you the basic
categories of what they are and what they're for, maybe some
popular drugs, and just, we'll talk about these a little bit.
So obviously, the first one's gonna be antidepressants. Everybody knows
about antidepressants. They're for depression. There's
commercials you've heard of probably Zoloft, Prozac, Paxil, Celexa. There's a bunch of other ones.
And these are various substances that essentially all have the
same effectivity, but some of them have less sedative effects. So the older ones would kind
of make you like zombie-like. Some people that have taken them
would describe that they just feel like mush and it dulls all
their senses, things like that. So they'll describe some of the
side effects like that, but there's varying degrees of how much it
makes you want to get up and do stuff versus how much it dulls
you. I don't know. I mean, it's got
a sedative effect. There are mood stabilizers. So
there's another category. This is for stuff like bipolar.
Lithium is a major one. There are others that I've never
heard of, and most of us have never heard of. But lithium is
a really old drug, but it has some pretty serious and dangerous
side effects. There's anti-obsessionals, which
you can probably guess are for obsessive compulsive disorders.
Zoloft is one of those. There's others. There's psychostimulants. These are things for like ADD,
ADHD. Ritalin, Adderall, some others
again that you've heard of. These are stimulants though.
Remember, they're stimulants. They're psychostimulants, but
they're basically amphetamines, which, I mean, that's like what
meth is. They're not straight meth, but
they're stimulants. So they have a kind of a tweaky
effect on you. There's a, I think I've mentioned
the documentary I watched recently about the psychostimulants. I
forget what it's called now, so it's probably in one of the
other lectures, but it's really interesting. But these get abused a lot by
young people, high school and college, especially college.
A lot of people think like you can't get through college unless
you're taking your Adderall, so you really focus in and get a
bunch of work done. They find that it makes them, feel like
they're concentrating really hard more than they're actually
concentrating and getting a bunch of work done, but that's why
they get abused. They have this tweaky effect
on you and you can just go and do stuff and get hyper-focused
on something, or at least it feels that way. Anti-psychotics
is another category. This is stuff for schizophrenia,
psychosis, hallucinations, delusions. This is the very serious type
mental illness stuff. Thorazine and Abilify. Abilify,
you may have heard of those. There's a bunch of others. Some
of these older drugs they found had, like Thorazine I think is
one of the older ones, it had some permanent severe side effects
to them. They thought the newer drugs
were much safer and new research is coming out that's showing
that they have different side effects, but just as severe.
There are serious ramifications from antipsychotics, or at least
there can be. It sounds kind of crazy, but
if you stay on some of these long-term, they have depressive
effects on you, the bipolar ones as well. Depression is a side
effect of long-term use of some of these drugs. I think antipsychotics
are used almost by all mass shooters have been on some kind of antipsychotic.
It's either that or antidepressant or both. I mean, don't quote
me on that because maybe I should edit that out of this recording.
A lot of them are on some sort of psychoactive drug though.
It's very, very, very common. Anxiolytics, these are for anxiety. Valium, Xanax, Zoloft, Paxil,
Klonopin. Those are popular ones you may
have heard of. Long-term use of some of these creates a tolerance. So this is like with the stuff
that you learned in DARE, the anti-drug stuff. You become tolerant
to it, so you need more and more of it to get that same effect.
Your body then becomes physically dependent on it, where if you
don't have it, you have all these negative side effects from not
doing it, and then you have withdrawal. So these have that sort of effect
most of the time. You need to get up up your doses
keep upping them to get that normal feeling to feel normal
and then They can even have life-threatening withdrawal symptoms. So Xanax
is one that actually has life-threatening withdrawal symptoms. And then
there's hypnotics, and these are things for, these are for
insomnia. Again, you've probably heard
of Ambien or Lunesta. The newer ones are less addictive.
Some of the older ones were more addictive, but they also can
have a a very confusing impact on the mind. If people wake up
in the middle of it and they've been on it, they can say and
do some pretty loopy things. So ultimately it's to help people
sleep, though, for people with this insomnia. You may have noticed
some crossover drugs across multiple categories. Things like Zoloft
are in, I think, like three of these. So these drugs are not
exactly precise and we understand relatively little about the neurobiological,
like literally what's happening in the brain, the components
of psychiatric problems. We don't necessarily understand
it, we can't fully grasp it, and we don't necessarily know
what's going on when these medicines get used on people. It's very,
very imprecise. It's sort of like the lobotomy
stuff that we talked about a few weeks ago, or a couple months
ago, I think I might have cited it in the first one, where they
started lobotomizing people by going to mental health institutions,
taking an ice pick, driving it into their eye socket, and literally
wiggling it around in their frontal lobe to change brain tissue. Basically destroy parts of it
and alter it and sometimes it really really helped people and
sometimes it destroyed them. So it's very very imprecise.
They're doing the same thing chemically now. Not that it's
literally just as imprecise, but there's significant imprecision
with it. It's also important to note that
every class of these drugs have common side effects. There are
significant side effects that people don't tend to know a lot
about. Drowsiness and weight gain are
very common. There's also a lot of sexual side effects. Decreased
libido and even inability to climax would be one of the side
effects. Some of these then lead to an
increased cause of depression. There's literally more reasons
to be sad and unhappy and anxious when you have some of these side
effects. So they can create a cycle almost. I mean, if your sexual
life is that messed up, I mean, it creates sadness. And if you
gain weight and you're sleepy all the time, that's very hard
to deal with. So the potential benefits from these drugs, even
when they do help, might not outweigh the negative side effects,
the cost of taking them. So recognize that these are not
benign drugs. That's not like no big deal.
It's not like taking an ibuprofen. You're changing what's going
on in your brain. It's pretty serious stuff. They
might help you and they might also harm you. So I want to ask
the question, are these drugs treating chemical imbalances?
We hear that idea talked about a lot, like, oh, I have a chemical
imbalance. Or you might have a chemical imbalance. You might
need this drug to help that chemical imbalance. So to talk about that,
we sort of have to know a little bit about how the brain works,
some neuroanatomy stuff. what's actually going on with
these, or at least what they think might be going on. There
are nerves in our brain. It's the nerve center of our
brain, right? There's neurons. And these neurons
communicate with each other with chemical substances called neurotransmitters. So they transmit information
between neurons. neurotransmitters, right? And
it's a chemical substance that goes between them and various
things happen once that happens. So the idea might be to like
block some of that transmission from being received or cause
more of it or things like that. You've heard of some of these
neurotransmitters too, like dopamine or serotonin. You can affect
some of these just by things that you do or ways that you
think. Dopamine feels pretty good. I like dopamine. You guys all like dopamine, you
probably just don't realize it, because things that you do that
make you feel good probably create dopamine in your brain. Some
theorize, so this chemical imbalance idea is, some theorize that there's
imbalances or dysfunctions in this system of how that works,
and those are the cause of psychiatric problems, mental illnesses. So
they'll say, oh, you have depression because you do not have enough
serotonin. Either it's not being created
or it's not being received, something along the lines of there's a problem
with the serotonin neurotransmitter. Therefore, take this medication
and that should treat that issue, should fix that depression. Now
ultimately, if that worked, if like Xanax or Prozac or something
like that, did that thing, and that was the problem, then depression
would be cured by taking that pill. And that does not happen.
You look at the studies of what happened when Prozac got introduced,
and if you look at the, it doesn't fix it, basically. So it's not
that simple. You cannot measure neurotransmitter
levels in the brain of a living person. You were just not capable
of doing it. You can't do that. You can't
find out what the dopamine or the serotonin, like what's happening
in a living person with those neurotransmitters. So it's impossible
to definitively prove that these drugs successfully change a person's
mood, even when the symptom is created. So this is different
from other medical conditions where levels of substances can
be measured in your blood, for instance, if you have diabetes
and you can measure blood sugar and you can figure out if a thing
is happening or being solved or hypothyroidism. You can take
blood tests and figure these things out. We cannot do this
with the brain. We do not have the ability to
do this. We don't even know exactly how these drugs work in humans,
which is a little bit of a scary thing, but We see how they work
on animal brain tissue in a test tube. And then we extrapolate
to that from humans of, if it does this to an animal brain
in a test tube, it could possibly do this to a human brain too.
And sometimes that's true and sometimes it's not. So nothing
is proven. And I wanna quote a pharmacologist
here. He says, we do not know the enzyme,
the receptor, or the genetic deficiency in any given psychiatric
disorder. So there is a lot of unknown
in this world. we don't really know if they
are fixing chemical imbalances. It's probably not the case that
we are, that these pills are doing that. They do seem to have
some impact on our neural networks, and they have some effect on
neurotransmission. So whatever that communication
process is with those chemical substances, if you alter those
chemical substances, or alter the way the neurons do that thing,
then you're having some impact on it, but it's very, very imprecise.
We know that that happens, and we know that that does reduce
symptoms in some people. But even when it does do that,
we don't know how it's doing that, or if the drug itself is
what's doing that. Zoloft might impact serotonin
interactions in the human brain. It might. But we don't know and
we can't know. We don't have the ability to
find out. It's not going to be possible to do that in the human
brain. And if it does do that, if it
does affect serotonin levels, we don't know if that will create
an antidepressant effect. So even though, even if we could
figure out it is doing the serotonin, messing with the serotonin, we
can't say definitively that's making the antidepressant effect
either. So these systems are extremely
complex. They are far beyond human capabilities
to research or understand. I think it's gonna be that way
permanently, maybe a thousand years in the future. I don't
know if we're gonna have enough of a window of time between now
and when Christ returns to develop the technology to actually do
some of this stuff. I think the human brain is so far beyond
our comprehension that we're just not gonna. And part of that,
I think is because of the scientifics' world's inability to deal with
the mind-body connection the way, because they deny any non-material
existence of things like a soul, the spiritual realm, but that
has an impact on the brain, and we're going to get to that. So God
designed the brain in this incredible way, and we're not going to be
able to understand it, and we also have to remember that correlation
does not equal causation. So the correlation of taking
an antidepressant to seeing antidepressant effects does not mean the antidepressant
caused the improvement. So that means like improvement in
depression does not necessarily, even if it correlates to taking
depression medication, doesn't mean that the depression medication
is causing the improvement in the depression. Remember the
placebo effect that we talked about from the first lecture,
I want to review a little bit about that. This is uncontroversial
accepted literature that at least 2 3rds, at least 2 3rds of depression
medication produces the placebo effect. This is just something
that's designed into us that causes the placebo effect to
genuinely work, or at least it appears to work to us, at least. So somehow when the human brain
has hope and expectation of a treatment or drug helping them to get better,
then it often does actually get better, even if there's no physical
or biological impact stemming from the treatment or the drug.
So the hope and expectation can create a biological impact, which
again is a very, it's just the complexity of these systems.
We don't know how that is, but it is. The change is produced
from the mind, from the thought of what might be or the hope
or the expectation of what might be. And that's just part of how
we're designed, apparently. Again, the brain and the neurological
system is extremely complex because We can know and scientists cannot
know that it's not merely physical. We know this as Christians with
a Christian worldview. We know that it's not merely
physical. We have a soul and somehow the
brain and the soul are connected. Our mind and body have a connection
and the way that we think and our soul interacts and science
can't measure that because they deny their materialist. They
don't believe in a metaphysical reality like a soul. We do. And because it's real and it
has a real impact, we can have an understanding that they can't
have. It's outside of their purview.
Science can't measure metaphysical things like a soul. You can't
measure it, contain it, size it up, tell you what color it
is, none of it. It's metaphysical. And they only can do physical
stuff. So, because we understand that we are spiritually, we're
spiritual beings, we're not just highly evolved animals, that
highlights one of the handicaps of the scientific realm. They can't explain things like
this. And not that we can't explain them, but we know at least a
little bit more of like, yeah, the soul has an impact on the
brain and vice versa. They can only analyze that physical
world, and so they can't react to the spiritual impact of the
physical world, and they can't suggest solutions in the spiritual
realm, even if one of the problems might be in the spiritual realm.
So they don't have that ability. They can't talk about sin and
temptation and how that affects the brain. We can. Or at least
we can know that it affects the brain, whereas they don't even
have that category. So they can't do that sort of
thing. So bottom line, These drugs might change some symptoms
in some people, but they cannot deal with our sin, they can't
deal with our soul, they can't deal with our spiritual state,
and all of those things have an impact on mental health. There's
mental health ramifications from the morality of your life, how
biblically you think, and the spiritual state of your soul.
And that will result in a biological impact in the way your brain
works. Where we at? Oh, and here's another thing
that we need to think about. When these drugs do work, because
sometimes they do, or at least they remove the symptom, not
necessarily the cause, but they can downplay the symptom, it
can give a false sense of success when it's merely masking the
problem. So you could potentially mask a problem with a drug and
not realize your problem is still persisting. It can demotivate you to address
the spiritual struggle as well, because the symptoms no longer
there. There's a spiritual struggle,
it's contributing to this problem and to a symptom, and if you
match the symptom, you don't really have any motivation or
zeal to deal with that problem in your life then. If it's a
spiritual problem, that's an issue. We're not zealous to do
spiritual work when we remove the negative consequences or
symptoms of those spiritual problems. So let's say you're anxious from
not trusting God, or you're doubting God's promises, and it makes
you anxious, and you encounter some bitter providence, some
hard providence in your life, and that makes you really anxious,
because you're starting to doubt that God works all things together
to good. Well, anti-anxiety drugs aren't really doing you any good
if you start to feel less anxious, but still aren't trusting these
promises of God. You can remove that symptom of
feeling anxious where the cause of the anxiousness, the anxiety,
is still there. And it's a spiritual problem
that you ought to address. So that doesn't mean don't ever
take anti-anxiety drugs. You can see a danger there. Or
if you're depressed from constant immoral behavior, that should
depress a Christian. Not necessarily like put you
in a depression tailspin or something, but you're gonna be more sad.
You're gonna be more depressed if you have constant immoral
behavior. And you could maybe mask some of that, take away
some of those symptoms to a degree by taking antidepressants. Maybe
they help and maybe they do get rid of that. But you're still
just muting a sadness that's there because you're doing something
wrong. And if you take away that sadness,
then you are then tempted to ignore that problem that's causing
it. Or at least not seek it out and dig in and do that work to
figure out that you're doing something wrong that's causing
this problem. So that still, that doesn't mean that these
drugs should never be used. But before using them, we need to
do much more in educating ourselves on what's happening and looking
at the things that the medical world and the psychiatric world
can't touch on. That sort of thing. They're not
gonna be able to tell you about your spiritual problem and how
it's causing depression or anxiety. They don't have that ability
because they don't have those categories. So how effective
are psychoactive medications? I'm gonna focus on antidepressants
here because the statistics show that there's more benefits. We just encounter that the most.
Antidepressants are the most commonly encountered thing in
the church in terms of mental illnesses. The statistics show
there are, they seem to be more beneficial the more severe the
depression is. So if you have very severe depression,
then you can, you usually have more substantial effect. The
antidepressants will help you more. But it is actually minimal
to nonexistent benefits for those that have moderate or mild depression. So unless it's severe, it likely
won't do much for you, or at least it will do very little.
That doesn't change, this is unfortunate, but it doesn't change
the difficulty in getting a prescription. If you go into a doctor and you
say, I'm depressed, I want an antidepressant, you're probably
gonna get one. Whether or not it's severe, whether or not it'll
probably help you. If you do that, you'll probably get one.
They're not difficult to get, but the benefit is heavily, heavily
weighted on the severe cases. There's, again, moderate to minimal
to nonexistent benefit for moderate or light depression. We can also
ask if antidepressants are more effective than counseling. for
depression. Individual studies show that
while medication may aid in the immediate time frame, so say
like the first four months, sometimes it aids in those first four months,
but after that four months, counseling is shown to be just as effective
as antidepressant medication, even in cases of moderate to
severe depression. So that is significant. Evidence
also shows that counseling is superior to medication in preventing
relapse, like falling back into severe depression. Counseling
is superior to a drug once they're stopped. So once you get out
of counseling or once you stop an antidepressant, you're more
likely to fall back into depression with the medication and not with
the counseling. Now there are some studies that
show that counseling and medication together are the most superior,
so there's some conflicting in terms of preventing relapse,
but counseling at least helps significantly and in most cases
is better. Ultimately. And that's just from
reported cases of individuals with it that have done it and
what they report. So that's what they say. So for us in the church, this
is important, let's apply this, for those of us that have friends
or maybe if we mentor someone that has depression or is depressed,
remember that forms of care that we can offer them actually have
been shown to be effective. and they're sometimes just as
effective or more effective than medication. What we can offer
to a depressed person can be just as good or better than medication,
and that's things like listening, questioning, reasoning, dialogue
with them, helping them to evaluate it, evaluate their thoughts,
challenging their assumptions and their behaviors, and then
helping them to change those thoughts and behaviors, because
if you change the thoughts and behaviors, you can change the
way their brain is working, because the brain is very, very plastic.
If you do these things and you can help someone's thoughts and
behaviors, then you can potentially help someone deal with depression.
I'm gonna repeat that, if you do these things. This is just
common stuff that happens in the church. If you do them, you
can help someone deal with their depression. So in other words,
helping them grow in spiritual maturity, or just a basic maturity
of life, and trusting God's attributes, trusting God's promises, who
he really is, who he said that he is, what he's really doing
with the world, helping this person to become more sanctified,
can help depression. I'm not saying this is the cure-all.
I'm saying this is something the church can do that you can
do if you have friends or if you're dealing with it. That's
a thing that has shown to help. Because counseling is going to...
Counseling is very beneficial. Therapy is very beneficial, and
sometimes often better than medication. What are they doing? They're
correcting incorrect thinking, more than anything. They're reminding
them of what the Bible says. Like, they'll say a thing, like,
well, what does the Bible say about that? It says you're wrong. I
know they don't do it that, you know, ham-fisted, but that's
basically what happens. You're not thinking biblically.
Start thinking biblically. God has said this about bad things
that have happened to you. God has said this about suffering.
Believe it. and that will help you not get
into this spiral of depression. There's other issues like schizophrenia
and mania or bipolar. Those almost always need some
kind of medication for the initial stabilization and then even long-term
management. Although, even in those cases,
counseling is still shown to be significantly helpful. The
bottom line, though, medications are not a silver bullet. that
they are not a silver bullet, especially when it comes to depression.
Though they may, for some people, at some times, for a period of
time, be part of the solution. Medications can affect us biologically. They change our brain patterns,
right? We can measure brain patterns
by PET scans and functional MRIs, and they prove this because counseling
and therapy do the same thing. It changes us biologically. Our brain changes through counseling
and therapy. And that means without some sort
of medical, biological intervention. So they both have an effect on
us biologically. Medications do it directly, and
then counseling and therapy do it indirectly. It changes something
about the way that we think and what we believe, and then we
start thinking different, and your brain will then work different.
differently. So in God's design, the body
still plays a role in the sanctification process. That's pretty important.
Anyone can help a struggling person by helping them to evaluate
and correct their thoughts, their emotions, their behavior, bring
them into line with God's law, help get over immoral behavior.
Immoral behavior or distrust of God's providence or his control
can affect your brain chemistry. You can have a biological impact
based on your beliefs in that area. when those things happen
to you. If two people are in a car accident together and they're
both paralyzed. It could put you into a depressive
state, right? That could send you into a depression
downward spiral. But if one person believes something
differently about what God is doing with that, it can prevent
that sort of thing from happening. Whereas with the other person,
they might not have the worldview. And then they could put them
into a PET scan and a functional MRI and see that their brains
are functioning differently. It changes your brain biologically. Just like, think about it this
way. If you think about a thing that gets you very, and I've
used this example, if you think about a thing that gets you really
excited, it can. create the way that you're thinking,
the thing that you're thinking about can get you very excited
in your brain and it can change the chemicals that are produced
and it'll change your heart rate, things like that. And I gave
that example once of the night before I was going skiing, I
kept staying up all night thinking about doing back flips and going
off these big ramps and I couldn't sleep because my heart rate was
just all night and I couldn't let my adrenaline go down. Purely
my brain, purely what I was thinking about with a biological impact.
So that's what we're talking about. Our thoughts and our emotions
and our desires and our motivations and our actions will correspond
to neural activity, your brain patterns. And we can control
those, or at least not like we become the master of them, but
to a degree, but we can shape our brain activity by controlling
Those things, by controlling your emotions and desires and
motivations and actions, you can help shape your brain activity.
That doesn't mean like it's completely at your whim, but you can have
an impact on it, and it can be a significant impact. And then
you can improve your brain activity, ultimately, with the Spirit's
help, and thus you can change your neural activity. Now this
isn't, this isn't something of like you're gonna master your
body and make your brain do whatever you wanna do. I'm saying, Your
spiritual state has a significant impact on how your brain works,
and that can be biologically measured. Not necessarily perfectly
described, but the impact can be measured. Also remember when
you're interacting with somebody that this mind-body connection
exists. Struggling, we don't bypass the body. So in 1st Kings
19, God prescribes for Elijah, he's extremely depressed, he's
moaning to God about these things, and he prescribes for him sleep,
food, and water. Like he was exhausted. He needed to lay down,
get some rest, he needed to get fed, and he needed to improve.
1 Timothy 5, Paul advises the medical use of wine. And we know
things like exercise are extremely helpful in our brain chemistry
in making you feel better. Like literally in the neurotransmitting
work, the things that are happening, it helps you feel better. Not
necessarily just your body's more fit, although that happens
too. But the immediate effects of exercise do that. When it comes to eliminating
suffering, because that's ultimately what this is. These issues are
forms of suffering. It is a good thing to eliminate
suffering, but we have to also remember that suffering is used
to transform us in the Kingdom of God. They're both goals in
the Kingdom of God, to eliminate suffering and to be transformed
by suffering. It's a little bit like money. I think suffering
is like money, that too much of it or too little of it can
both be very hazardous to our spiritual state. So, if you never
ever suffer, you're likely not growing very much spiritually.
Extreme suffering makes us want to question God. It makes us
want to give in. Kind of the curse God and die
mentality of Job's wife. It makes you get fearful and
angry. But at the same time, too little suffering causes us
to lose our sense of dependence on God and to forget him because
we just tend to do that. We can become complacent and
we become self-reliant. We see this pattern with the
Israelites. Whenever God made it go good in the land, they
slip into idolatry. They're just like, okay, we're
fine. We don't need him. What do we need him for? Well,
he's making it go good. And then they slip into idolatry and then
they get judged. There's a really good proverb here. And ladies,
you can use this for the women's retreat. Proverbs 38 and nine. Give me neither poverty nor riches.
Feed me with the food that is my portion, that I may not be
full and deny you and say, who is the Lord? that I not be in
want and steal and profane the name of my God. So that idea of like, don't give
me too much or too little. There's danger in both. And that's
actually true with suffering as well. So, what does that have
to do with medications? Well, when it comes to using
them, don't be too quick to immediately alleviate any and all suffering. Because God uses trials, God
uses our trials, right? So do that hard work of maybe
finding the source, or maybe some of the problems, or at least
the spiritual problems that might be contributing to those mental
issues. Not that you, this doesn't mean
you don't use them, but be careful to just, you know, oh, this'll
fix it, this'll fix it, get rid of it immediately, be careful
about that. That doesn't mean we never use them, obviously, We also shouldn't think that
we're being more spiritual by prolonging suffering unnecessarily. I mean, no one here is probably
going to not take the ibuprofen in the cabinet just because it's
a spiritual thing to suffer through their headache, right? But at
the same time, learn through your headache. So just don't
go to one extreme or the other. These medications can be a gift,
and they can be an idol. So be thankful that we have them,
that they can sometimes alleviate symptoms. Sometimes they're appropriate
to take. But if you are in a position
where the benefits of taking them outweigh the negative side
effects, then be sure that they're only part of your treatment.
Do not rely on them exclusively. Don't think, I'm dealing with
my depression by taking this antidepressant and that's it.
If you're not treating your spiritual state while you're dealing with
these issues, with any of these mental health issues, then you're
likely idolizing the medication, or at least you're trusting it
in an improper way. So do things with your spiritual
state that Be as faithful to coming to church as you do taking
your pills. Be as faithful of being in the word and going to
God in prayer as you do taking your antidepressant meds, right?
That sort of thing. Feed your spiritual soul and
make sure you're in spiritual health and let that factor contribute
if you're in a state where you need to take pills. Don't take
medication as an excuse to avoid examining yourself spiritually.
We're looking closely at underlying issues. Don't just be like, I'm
going to take this and then I'm not going to ask myself why I'm
depressed. Don't do that kind of thing.
Don't take it because of pressure from friends or family, because
you're a pain in their neck. Don't do that. And then don't
take it to attain victim status for yourself of like, I am a
depressed person. I have depression. Look, I have
this. I'm taking an antidepressant. All these things that I'm doing
that are wrong are fine because I have depression. Don't try
and get the victim status on yourself and then excuse certain types of behavior or
patterns of thought. It'll make patterns of thought more difficult,
it doesn't excuse it though. Remember we talked about that
before. It makes things more difficult, it doesn't control
your brain in the sense of making you think things or making your
body do things. But at the same time, there are
cases, though these are usually more extreme, where a failure
to take a medication makes it more difficult to address spiritual
problems. We all struggle with patience
and anxiety and anger when we don't get the proper amount of
sleep or rest, right? We have a shorter temper, we're
not nearly as nice, and if we cannot get rest, if you have
severe insomnia, but you refuse to take a sleep aid because you're
just like, hey, I'm too spiritual for that or something like that,
then you're making it more difficult to solve the problem because
you're gonna stay in that constant inflamed state that's very, very
difficult. Even though your exhaustion doesn't excuse those kind of
sins, but... There's times when you might
need to take a medication to kind of calm those down. The
way he described it, it's like it's calming the surface waters
for a deep sea exploration. If you need to take it for just
to stabilize, take a medication to stabilize it in some form
so that you can dive in and figure out what's going on. So they
can be helpful in severe cases of depression or anxiety or when
experiencing delusions or hallucinations from schizophrenia. You usually,
you can't, Talk someone out of delusions and hallucinations. You can't talk someone out of
that. So there's times when these meds are very helpful for actually
doing that counseling work and analyzing the thoughts and stuff
like that. I haven't given a lot of direct quotes, but here's
one from page 86. It's not that you can buy holiness in a pill,
but using medication in certain situations may help bodily conditions
that allow for a greater spiritual flourishing. And the idea is,
if you want to flourish fully, you have to do that hard spiritual
work, and sometimes you have to calm down these bodily issues
to enable that sort of work to start happening. They can help,
they can aid in that case. All right, so wrapping it up,
getting some conclusions here. Psychoactive medication may help
a certain percentage of individuals, but the benefits of psychoactive
medication do not meet the level advertised by pharmaceutical
companies or believed by popular opinion. Most people have the
idea, if I'm depressed, I take an antidepressant and I'm basically
fine. It's not even close to that simple,
not even close. Also, the side effects are frequently
far more severe and pervasive and hazardous than most people
realize, and a lot of these studies are coming out to clue us in
on that. Let us know that, wait, this
is far more severe than we realized. These drugs are still pretty
new, and this idea of tinkering with your brain and how little
we know of what's actually happening is a very, very serious thing. Nobody should just be going to
their doctor just like a general practitioner and saying, I'm
depressed, I need an antidepressant, and getting it and taking it.
That shouldn't happen. It should not be that simple. That happens
all the time. When seeking relief, one ought
to target both the body and the moral, spiritual aspects of your
life. So not just what's going on with your body, not just what's
happening chemically in your brain or biologically, not just
how much sleep and exercise you're getting, but the moral spiritual
aspects of life. Those are a significant factor
to these issues. Address sin, address personal
relationship with God, address how much you're trusting God,
what you believe about the gospel, what you believe about sanctification
and providence, all those things, moral spiritual aspects of life.
They both need to be part of treatment. Like with various
leg injuries, he gives a good example here. Sometimes it's
like using crutches in a time of recovery. There's a period
of recovery where you need crutches and meds can be that way for
mental issues. Some mental problems are not
severe enough to require it. Maybe you need a walking boot,
but you don't need crutches. You don't need to be on meds. But then
some are. If the leg is broken, you probably
need a crutch for a time period. And then sometimes crutches can
be used to prevent recovery because the person is kind of refusing
to bear the pain that comes from strengthening like if you have
a leg injury an ankle injury and it hurts when you walk well
sometimes you have to like strengthen those muscles back up because
you haven't been using them so you need to get off the crutches
and start bearing that pain until you learn your body re-acclimates
and strengthens itself and And meds can be like that, where
you might need them for a period, but maybe people tend to lean
on them like a crutch at times too often. Most psychiatrists
do not recommend taking an antidepressant more than nine to 12 months before
probably stopping it or weaning off of it. Again, we talked about
how general practitioners are usually the ones prescribing
these kind of drugs, but if you go to an actual psychiatrist
where it's their field of expertise, they know a little bit more about
the danger of being on them long-term, and they don't recommend more
than a year, usually nine to 12 months, and it's like, all
right, we need to reevaluate and probably get you off of these. So it's
only in very severe cases where it's gonna be a long-term, some
sort of medical intervention with medications. You may or
may not be able to solve some of the mysterious causes of mental
problems, because like we said, our brains are incredibly complex
and we cannot explain the soul-mind connection fully, but you can
always develop a more spiritually mature framework for dealing
with the symptoms in a truth-saturated biblical way. So if you're dealing
with depressive symptoms and anxiety symptoms, you can still,
even if you don't even have access to meds, let's say you don't
have health insurance and you don't even know how to go about
getting them, you can still go about developing a spiritually
mature framework to think about these things in a biblical way,
by attacking them with truth. Because if we believe all true
things, you're not gonna be anxious and you're not gonna be depressed.
Almost all of it is going to be rooted in some untrue thing
that we deal with, or that in combination with bad things that
have happened in our lives. It's a combination of factors.
But if you always believe true things, which obviously no one's
going to do, but you can get closer and closer to that through
maturity, you can be dealing with these things. So whether
you are dealing with mental problems personally, or if you're meeting
with someone who is, or if you know someone in this church who
is, or one of your friends is, know that godly thinking and
behavior will always help those who are suffering. You can always
help. You don't have to be a doctor
that has access to these meds to help your friends or to help
yourself if you're struggling in these issues. You can help
yourself through sanctification. It's not going to always cure
it, but it's going to be a significant factor, and it can help very,
very much in this process. So that's all I had for tonight. Again, if you want this book,
It's pretty small and super easy to read. You can read it in like
a night or two. So I hope that equips this church a little bit
more for dealing with these. If you guys want to keep going
on biblical counseling and depression and anxiety type issues specifically,
let me know. And we'll keep diving in because
I got more books I actually want to cover, things like ADD, ADHD,
and depression specifically, and talk about those in a very
direct way, because we're talking, we're laying the groundwork to
do that by talking about diagnoses and medication, but I think there's
a lot more that we can do talking about specific things that are
dealt with more often. So let's pray quick and then
have a closing hymn. Heavenly Father, we do ask that
you would help us in this church to be more and more equipped
to deal with those that struggle with mental illness, or if our
friends do, our family does, or if we ourselves do. We pray that we would first and
foremost trust in you and your promises and your truth to deal
with these issues. We pray that we can exercise
extreme discernment and wisdom and care when it comes to the
question of whether or not to take medication. And I pray that
if we are having negative side effects, we would have the courage
to come off or to change, whatever it may be. Give us wisdom here,
Lord. These are things that are beyond
most of our understanding, but we do trust that you have endowed
each one of us with a soul, that each one of us is an embodied
soul, and that you have made a connection between our bodies
and our souls. It's very, very complex because
you're an incredibly creative and amazing designer. And we're
not going to fully understand these things, so we pray that
we trust in you and combat them with what we do have, the fruits
of the Spirit and godliness and holiness and the fruit that comes
from that and how that can help us in this area. So help us to
do that well in this church. We pray it all in Christ's name.
Amen.
Mental Illness, Diagnoses, & Medications from a Biblical Perspective, Part 3
Series Biblical Counseling
| Sermon ID | 95192364383 |
| Duration | 49:15 |
| Date | |
| Category | Midweek Service |
| Bible Text | Proverbs 30:8-9 |
| Language | English |
Documents
Add a Comment
Comments
No Comments
© Copyright
2026 SermonAudio.
