00:00
00:00
00:01
Transcript
1/0
Ecclesiastes chapter 3, reading
from the verse number 1. To everything there is a season
and a time to every purpose unto the heaven, a time to be born
and a time to die, a time to plant and a time to pluck up
that which is planted, a time to kill and a time to heal, a
time to break down and a time to build up, a time to weep and
a time to laugh, a time to mourn and a time to dance. A time to
cast away stones and a time to gather stones together. A time
to embrace and a time to refrain from embracing. A time to get
and a time to lose. A time to keep and a time to
cast away. A time to rend and a time to
sow. A time to keep silence and a
time to speak. A time to love and a time to
hate. A time of war and the time of
peace. Amen. We know that God will bless
the reading of his word to our hearts. Let's seek the Lord for
prayer. Father in heaven, as we come
to you tonight, as we come to consider your word in the light
of this bill that has been proposed, we pray that you would give us
wisdom and understanding. and strengthen us in our resolve
for the things that are truthful and right and beautiful which
thou hast given to us. And strengthen us in our resolve
to pray against that which is wrong and evil and help us to
appreciate the life that God has given and help us to enrich
others with our lives. And so we pray that you would
write your word upon our hearts. May the words of my mouth, the
meditation, of my heart be acceptable in thy sight oh lord my strength
and my redeemer amen and amen tonight we are going to consider
the subject assisted dying is it compassionate or cruel and
we're looking really at the christian response to euthanasia because
while assisted dying isn't quite euthanasia there is every indication
that it comes from the same philosophical background and will lead in that
direction. So we're going to think about
this tonight and it's important that we should consider this
Bill in the light of God's Word and of God's truth. And here
in Ecclesiastes chapter 3 and the verse 2 we have a text which
really is a very good place to start. Where the Bible says concerning
our lives There is a time to be born and a time to die. And
who is the one that has that time? It is God. That time is in His hands because
the psalmist said, my times are in thy hands. On Friday, the
29th of November this week, The House of Commons will have its
first opportunity to vote on the Private Members Bill proposed
by Labour MP for the Spen Valley, Kim Leadbeater. This bill, if it becomes law,
will bring about the single biggest social change that our nation
has ever seen. apart from perhaps David Steele's
1967 abortion bill, which actually was also a private member's bill. The difference between abortion
and assisted dying is that one affects children who have never
had the opportunity of life, while the other concerns people
who are living and who no longer want life. Kim Leadbeater's assisted
dying for the terminally ill adults bill have passed, will
not legislate for Northern Ireland, it only concerns England and
Wales. But crucially, our MPs, as is true of the Scottish MPs
as well and the Welsh MPs, they will all have a vote, the devolved
nations will all have a vote. And so that's immediately, tells
us that this does concern us because our MPs will have a vote.
Not only that, but there are bills passing through Holyrood
in Edinburgh, and there are bills passing through the Dáil in Dublin,
and these pieces of legislation are moving all of the kingdoms
around us in the direction of assisted dying. There is a juggernaut
driving this social change across the entirety of the British Isles. And if Kim Leadbeater's bill
succeeds, then this little piece of ground, these six counties,
could very possibly be the only place in these islands which
does not have assisted dying or euthanasia. And if that is
the case, then we know it is inevitable that the very same
battle is going to be fought on Ulster soil. And there will
be those who will want to introduce the change to Ulster. But if
this bill is defeated, if it is stayed and held back in the
principal legislature within the United Kingdom. Well, the
Republic of Ireland may likely go down the route of assisted
dying, but it might just save us. And so we should have an
interest in what is going on at Westminster at this time.
Now, the purpose of this message is twofold. It's important that
we understand why the ethos underlying this bill is entirely wrong.
We need to get that. Why? It is in opposition to the
word of God. And the word of God gives us
a Christian worldview, a Christian view of the world. And this bill
contradicts the Christian view of the world. But there's another
purpose for this message as well. As Christians, we have a duty
to promote the preciousness of human life. Every person has
a real and a remarkable purpose in this world. We are all precious,
we are all important, every one of us. I was speaking to some
teenagers recently and I brought up this subject and I looked
at all of them and I said, you're all important, you're all precious,
there's a great purpose for you in this world. And what this
bill does is undermine that. And as Christians, we need to
possibly get that message out. God's view of humanity, it's
a high and noble view, despite the twisted nature of our sin. Before moving into the subject
properly, there are some details concerning the bill, and then
there are some concerns around the bill that I want to bring
before you by way of introduction. So what are the details of the
bill now? This bill does not introduce
euthanasia. Euthanasia is where the state
takes upon itself the power to remove the human life. Where
the doctor will inject the poison and take the person's life away.
That's euthanasia. The word euthanasia actually
means mercy killing. The whole idea behind euthanasia
is that you're performing an act of mercy and taking the person
out of their suffering. And that's why the word euthanasia
isn't used in the title of the bill. It's assisted dying. So what is assisted dying? Well,
if this bill is passed, the state will have the power to assist
the individual in the taking of their own life. So the individual
must be able to take their own life. The individual must be
able to apply the medicine, the drug, but the doctor will provide
it. The NHS will provide it, or taxes
will provide for it. The phrase assisted dying is
actually really misleading. Satan is so clever at using all
kinds of terms to gloss over what's actually happening. For
example, in countries where euthanasia is practiced, you don't read
about the state killing people. You read about this phrase, that
person has been euthanized, euthanized. It's the phrase they use. States
don't sponsor murder, that's what it is. And assisted dying
is not assisted dying. Assisted dying, properly speaking,
is palliative care. And the nurses and doctors who
provide palliative care for the dying do an amazing job. And they help the individual
die naturally. And they will use drugs and medicines
to relieve the suffering all of the while they are preserving
life. And as far as they can, they
try and preserve consciousness in order that the person might
leave this world naturally. That is assisted dying. That's palliative care. But nature
takes its course. This law, if passed, is assisted
suicide. the individual will be presented
with the medication to take their own life. And that's the true
nature of Kim Leadbeater's proposal. Now, she claims that she has
built in safeguards. The major safeguard, as far as
she is concerned, relates to those having a terminal illness.
So you have to be certified by a A doctor is having less than
six months to live. And she was, she's saying, look,
look, it's not going to apply to the disabled and it's not
going to apply to people that are mentally ill and all of these
things. It's just going to apply to a certain group of people
who are suffering and who are facing death in the very near future. And as far as she is concerned,
that's a safeguard. But is it? Now, Let's just think
about some areas of concern in relation to the bill. And again,
this is all by way of introduction before we come to look at what
the scripture says. Now, we do have the utmost sympathy
for people that are suffering. And this is one of the points
that is made in support of this change in legislation, that we
should have a heart for people that are suffering. people that
they don't want to suffer anymore as they come to die. Would it
not be better just to have them slip away in their sleep as a
result of applying some lethal medicine? Would that not be easier?
Surely we should have a heart for those people. We do have the utmost sympathy
for the suffering. Of course we do. Our hearts go
out for them. Our hearts break for them. But
is it not even more tragic to say to these people, death is
an option. This is what we're providing
you with. Let's provide you with death. This is what we're going
to do. And so that becomes a real option
for those people, a real legal option, a moral option. Here's
death, you can have it. Is that kind? Is that merciful? Is that good? What sort of a
hope does that give? And so that is a huge area of
concern that we would have. Now, euthanasia and, indeed,
assisted suicide, because the two things come from the same
philosophy. They stem from the idea that
some human lives are not worth living. We're all special. Whatever position
in life we're in, whatever capabilities or lack of capabilities we have,
whether we're young or whether we're older, whether we're near
life's end, we're still special. Every life is worth living and
every life has value and every life has meaning. But this philosophy
says some lives are not worth living. That entirely contradicts. this biblical view of humanity,
the Christian view of humanity. Another big area of concern is
this. The National Health Service will cross the boundary from
caring for the suffering to facilitating death. Institutions such as nursing
homes, hospitals, which are designed to relieve suffering while preserving
life, will become places where death will be the outcome by
design. People die in all of these places. They do. It's a
journey of life. But they are not designed to
produce death. But suddenly, the National Health
Service will, in some places, become the National Death Service.
Now that already has happened tragically with abortion, with
the extremely liberal and dangerous abortion laws that we have in
this country. It's so wicked and it's so vile
what is happening with the taking of the lives of the unborn, but
now it will happen to those at the other end of life's journey. Doctors and nurses whose task
is to protect life will become party to the ending of life.
Death will suddenly become a treatment. Just think of that. Death becomes
a treatment. The boundary will be crossed. And that's a very dangerous development
for the health service of any country. Another area of concern is this.
Limiting the application of the legislation to those with six
months to live, that will prove impossible to define. A doctor
generally knows if an individual has hours or days left. As one who frequently has been
by the bedside of the dying, I can see the hand of death stealing
over the body. as you visit and come back, you
can see it. And those of you who have seen
loved ones dying will know what I am talking about. But six months,
six months. How often has a doctor's predictions
not been accurate? How many people have defied all
of the odds and have lived? How many people were given a
very short time to live and suddenly they have lived? for perhaps
years afterwards. It has happened. And I would
suggest that this restriction is just a tactic. It's just a
tactic to get this bill over the line. And then in future
years, amendments will come. The six months will quickly be
dropped and we'll be into full-blown euthanasia. You see what this
bill is all about, surrendering the principle. You surrender
the principle that the government can take life. And once you surrender
that principle, you have no idea where it's all going to lead
us to. Now, experience has shown, in
other countries where euthanasia or assisted dying has been introduced,
the initial restrictions were eventually eroded. The Netherlands
is one of the best examples. They have had assisted dying
and euthanasia for a very long time. The definition in the Netherlands
for receiving euthanasia was that you had to be experiencing,
the term was unbearable suffering. Unbearable suffering. Now that
is now applied to people suffering from dementia. It's now being
applied to people who suffer from mental illness in rising
numbers. There is a very striking example
in the Netherlands of this. There was a couple from the town
of Tilburg they became very well known. They became minor celebrities
actually in their local area in November 2016. They agreed
to the euthanasia of their son. Their son was very overweight. He suffered from severe mental
illness. And at 38 years of age, they
had him and the term was euthanized. They said, you try to make your
child happy, but Elko, that was his name, wasn't happy in life.
He wanted to stop suffering. Death was the only way. That's what parents did for their
son. Canada, the Prime Minister of
Canada, Justin Trudeau, whenever assistant dying was introduced,
he said these restrictions would not be dropped within five years
they were dropped. And Canada now is one of the
most liberal regimes in the entire world. The story is told of Rosina
Camus. She had fibromyalgia and chronic
leukemia. She also had mental and physical
illnesses. She presented these symptoms
to the assessors. Her death was approved. She left
a note that was only to be made known after she died. And the
note simply said, please keep all this secret while I am still
alive because the suffering I experience is mental suffering, not physical.
I think if more people cared about me, I might be able to
handle the suffering caused by my physical illness alone. That
was her cry. She died by lethal injection.
Forty-one years of age. That is just the tip of the iceberg.
Where this kind of philosophy leads a country and a nation
to. So, we should be totally concerned
by what we are seeing in this bill. Let's think about the Christian
worldview. Let's think about what the It's a very sensitive matter.
It's a matter that touches all of our lives because we're all
living and in a sense we're all dying. We are. We're going down
the valley one by one. Suffering is all around us. It's
part of the fabric of humanity. It's very real and it's very
personal. But let's think about what the scriptures have to say
about this Christian worldview which is entirely opposed to
this assisted dying bill. The first point I want to make
is this. The Christian worldview teaches the sanctity of life. The Bible says we've been created
in the image of God. The Bible says that Human life
is totally different from animal life. There is a sacredness in
humanity which sets us apart and makes us special. Now I know
that to a person who is not religious, a person who perhaps is atheistic,
that seems totally foreign. And how can we use that kind
of language to win over the argument whenever there are people out
there who don't believe in God and yet we know there are people
out there who don't believe in God who are totally opposed to
this legislation too. They're not happy with it and
there's voices in Parliament speaking up and they come from
an entirely different faith perspective from us. But those people, while
they may not realize it, They believe in the sanctity of life.
They believe that human life should not be violated because
that's what God teaches in his word. God made man in his own
image. In the image of God made he him,
male and female, created he them. And I think there's a real message
for the church to get out, speak out for. Why is human life special? Because We are made by God. Genesis 2 verse 7, the Lord God
formed man of the dust of the ground and breathed into his
nostrils the breath of life and man became a human soul. So on this account, the removal
of human life is a violation. It's a violation of the sacredness.
It's a violation of the special nature of humanity. The killing
of humanity, the killing of humanity. the removing of the life of humanity,
whether it is by murder or by manslaughter, by suicide, by
assisted suicide, even by neglect. All of this is covered within
the scope of the sixth commandment, where Exodus 20 verse 13 says,
thou shalt not kill. And that's very straightforward
language. Thou shalt not kill human life. is special, it is not to be violated,
it is to be treated with the utmost care. And that's how we
should look at our own lives, and that's how we should look
at the lives of others. And that is a principle that
should undergird a state and how it looks after the lives
of its citizens. You see, because we've been made
in the image of God, because God has created us, we must see
life as a gift. That's really important, life
as a gift. If someone gives you a gift, you're trusted with that
gift. And you want to treat that gift in a very special way because
someone has given you that. You don't want to appear unkind
or ungrateful. You have a duty to take that
gift and use it. And the more the person means
to you, I suppose, the more special that gift becomes. The great
creator, who's also the great benefactor, he has given us the
gift of life. You know, people say today, I
should be able to do what I want. I should be able to be what I
want, do what I want, believe what I want, do with this body
as I want. If I want to die, I die. That's
where all this is leading us to, but the Bible says God has
given us the gift of life. And all of the lives that we
have tonight, every one of you, That life of yours is a gift
from God. And he has given you that gift for his glory. You
might use it for him, but he's also given you that gift for
the good of others. There's such a selfish spirit
abroad today, but that gift is for the good of others. And it's
not our right to remove that precious gift that God has given,
but to use that gift to enrich others. How sacred and how special
this life is that God has given to us. Carl Gunning is a good
example. He was a doctor in the Netherlands. He spent a large part of his
career fighting against the trend in the Netherlands towards Euthanasia
and Assisted Suicide. And he said this in a book written
in 1990. It's a series of articles written
by various experts. The book's called Death Without
Dignity, Euthanasia in Perspective. He said this. Until now, deliberate
killing has been regarded as something abhorrent in Western
society. If we begin to accept killing as a good thing in order
to solve one kind of problem, then we shall soon find reason
to use killing in order to solve other kinds of problems. And
history provides many examples of the kind of society we get
if killing is regarded as good. And he would go on to describe
what happened in Nazi Germany. We must decide what kind of society
we really want for ourselves and for future generations. Killing
can never be regarded as good. The sanctity of human life. And then, secondly, let us think
about the sovereignty of God over life. God is a sovereign
God. He has given us our lives, and
as the one that has given us our lives, he also has the right
to remove our lives in his time. And of course, that time is coming
for us all, isn't it? And we don't know when that will
come, but that time must always be in God's hands. Job understood
this as he faced his afflictions. He said, naked came I out of
my mother's womb and naked shall I return thither. The Lord gave
and the Lord had taken away. Blessed be the name of the Lord.
And as our text of the wall says, there's a time to be born and
a time to die. You see, the secular humanist
and this whole philosophy, it stems from secular humanism.
It's got an evolutionary mindset. It sees the world in terms of
evolution. Nature is red in tooth and claw. It's just a struggle. Life is
a struggle. It's a struggle filled with pain
and ultimately only the fittest survive. There's no real enjoyment
there. There's no pleasure there. It's
all about just getting by. It's all about surviving. It's
about procreating as well. It lowers humanity just to the
animal. And to be part of the evolutionary
struggle is not to enjoy the gift of life. It's to be condemned
to life with all of the hardships that life brings. It's a nightmarish
existence. And death is just a release from
that nightmarish existence. And as far as the evolution is
concerned, death just releases us back to the nothingness from
which we came. There's no meaning in that. There's
no meaning in that. To think of this great God that
has made us, has created us, that has our lives in the palm
of his hand, isn't that much better? More hopeful? Isn't that
a better message? Doesn't that give us greater
meaning? The Christian faith really has
a message for this doomed and desperately unhappy world of
which we are a part, but we are called to be lights in this world.
And the sovereignty of God is a great lesson. We can leave
everything in his hands. Let's move on and think about
the soul and its eternity after death. Now, the soul and its
eternity after death. have we got that slide boys?
Maybe I Okay, we'll just come on back. Yes, stay stay with
this one. Let's think about the soul and its eternity after death. The the scriptures teach that
man's soul is immortal. This is what the Bible teaches.
The the soul of man is immortal. The purpose of life is to prepare
for judgment and for our In the book of Hebrews chapter
nine in the verse twenty-seven, we read, it is appointed unto
man once to die, but after this, the judgment. Now, to provide
someone with the means of removing their lives sends that person
out to eternity to meet with God. Now, of course, this philosophy
is born out of the false idea there is no God. If there's no
God, there's no judgment. If there's no judgment, there's
no heaven, there's no hell. There's no Nothingness. So on this account,
because of what we know about the soul of man, because of what
we know about eternity, because of what we know about all of
this, this whole philosophy, it's cruel. And I said that the
title was Compassion or Cruelty. It is cruelty. Because the purpose
of life, what is the purpose of life? To prepare to meet God.
The purpose of life is to get to the cross of Christ, see our
sins, have those sins taken away by the blood of Jesus Christ.
That's the purpose of life. It's to know God. And it's to
be forgiven by God. It's to be prepared for the judgment
day. That's the purpose of life. For it is appointed unto man
once to die and after this, the judgment. And this philosophy
removes the precious time that an individual could be using.
to get saved and come to Christ. And this is a message that we
need to keep making to this corrupt world of which we're a part,
isn't it? That men and women are going out to meet God. And
let me challenge you tonight, because you might say, I don't
believe in this stuff. I believe there's a God, and
I believe there's a time to die, and I don't believe in what the
law Makers are planning to do some of them. I don't believe
in that. But what do you believe? Are you prepared for eternity?
That's the key thing. Because if you die without Christ,
your soul will be lost too. But God has given you this gift
of life, this gift of time, this precious moment when you can
prepare to meet God. And I would encourage you to
use that time tonight. To come to the Lord and to cry
unto him for salvation before the time to die reaches your
door. Now let's think about the suffering
and their purpose in the world. And suffering does have a purpose
in life. There is a purpose in suffering. There's such a difference between
society yesterday and society today, at least in part. It strikes
me when I read history and read about people dying, people living
centuries ago, and even not so long. they they died in terrible
pain. There wasn't the same pain relief
there is now. And you you read about some of
these accounts and it's just awful. George Whitfield, a great
preacher, died suffering from an asthma attack only in his
mid fifties and the accounts, the eyewitness accounts, it's
it'll break your heart. A dear man of God. there wasn't this appetite for
having the life removed before God's time came. Let's put the
person out of their suffering. Somebody put me out of my suffering.
Despite the enormous suffering, there was the acceptance that
this is how it is and I'll accept my lot in life even though it
is so difficult. And that was because there was
a deep Christian consciousness permeating society. But the contrast with today is
striking because pain can be managed in a way that it wasn't
managed in the past. The palliative care is excellent.
The palliative care in the UK, there needs to be more investment
in it, but we do have excellent facilities and great team of
caring doctors and nurses looking after those that are suffering.
So despite all of that, The growing clamor for euthanasia and assisted
suicide had become louder and louder and almost deafening at
times. And the liberal lobby would make
you think that the momentum is unstoppable, it's going to happen.
And why is that? Why is that? It is because of
the godless spirit that permeates our society. And death, the great
symbol of the curse, is seen as something that is good. and
people fail to realize that God performs a purpose for us in
this world, even through our pain and our suffering. There was a young doctor who
wrote a book back in 1982. He was dying. His name was James
Cassin. And the title of the book is
interesting, Dying the Greatest Adventure of My Life. Only somebody
that was actually dying could have written that. this is what
he said. Dying makes life suddenly real.
Watching my slow physical deterioration, reaffirm my belief that there
is something else within which could only survive if only because
my personality stayed the same in spite of the eroding bodily
form in which it was confined. As death was coming, he felt
the reality of life and he could see a purpose in all of that. You see, our Reinforce that everybody has
a purpose. Even those that suffer have a
great and a remarkable and a wonderful purpose. You go into a nursing
home and there's so many people in profound illnesses, incapacity. dementia. They're to be treasured. And they're to be loved. And
they're to be appreciated. Someday, who knows the situations
that we'll be in in life. And we hope and we pray that
the people to love and to treasure us. And those that suffer, we
watch them suffer. And that teaches us lessons. That's why we need to be there
to comfort those that are suffering. Because their suffering enriches
our lives. It teaches us something about humanity. The same is true
of the disabled. And tragically, where euthanasia
begins to get a foothold, those that are disabled are seen as
people who could avail themselves of this treatment, this warped
humanity sees it. But those that are disabled have
so much to teach us and to enrich our lives with and perform a
great and remarkable purpose in the eyes of God. Every life is important, you
see. and even those that suffer. There's a ministry through their
suffering. Lessons for us all, they're not to be discarded.
The psalmist said, cast me not off in time of old age, forsake
me not when my strength faileth. Is that not a good reference?
I think it is. Christianity teaches true compassion.
It is argued that this bill is compassionate, it's not. Christianity,
giving people worth in the midst of their suffering, that's true
compassion. Teaching there's a great friend
in Christ who never leaves us, that's true compassion. Finally, let's think about the
satisfaction to be gained through enjoying life. The gospel gives us a satisfaction
in this world. You know, man becomes consumed
with death in a most unhealthy way. This idea of, is this the
suicide euthanasia? It's a most unhealthy view of
the world and of life and of death. But God's interested in
life. Thus saith the Lord, behold,
I set before you the way of life and the way of death. That's
what Jeremiah said to King Zechariah, I set before you the way of life
and the way of death. And what is life? What is life? How do we see life? Do we see
life just in terms of breath and a brain that ticks and a
beating heart and the DNA and all of those things that make
up the fabric of our humanity? And of course, that's all very
part of our physical being, but is that all there is to life?
Of course it's not. We have the Spirit within. We
have everlasting existence, whether in God's heaven or God's hell.
And there's a way to escape hell, and that's through Christ, who
gave his life for us, and who rose again. Now, there's the
message we need to get out there, that Christ died, and in his
dying, he defeated death, and he rose again, in order that
we might live for eternity. That's the gospel. That's the
gospel. There is a way of death, and
there's a way of life. I wonder tonight, are you in
the way of life? Are you in the way of death?
What direction are you going? Remember this gift we've been
talking about? Even this time, this moment spent
in God's house, it's a gift that will not come again. I'm not
saying you will never hear the gospel again, dear unsafe friend.
You may well do. I can't guarantee that you will.
But this moment will never come again. For every moment is to
be treasured. And the real challenge is, what
will you do with Christ? There's real satisfaction to
be found in life. Whatever our circumstances, whatever
our pains, our afflictions even, there's real satisfaction to
be found in Jesus. but you need to know him as your
savior to realize our purpose. What can we do? This wicked legislation,
which if passed, this proposed legislation, which if it is passed,
it will, as I have said, will have catastrophic influence upon
the course of our nation, upon the health care of our nation
in the future. What can we do? What can we do about all of that. Well, we can pray. And yes, I
do think we should write to those in our authority. We should do
that, but we should pray. And we should pray that God would
overrule the king's heart is in the hand of the Lord. As the
rivers of water, he turneth it withers wherever he will. There's
a sovereign God who can control what happens in parliament this
week. So we should pray. But in our
praying, let's pray for the sick and the suffering. Let's pray
for those who look after the sick and the suffering. Let's
pray for the suffering who do not have the hope of the gospel
that God would turn them to himself. And let's pray for ourselves
that God would help us to get the real message of the gospel
out to this dying world. Because unless this country is
changed by the gospel, these kinds of depravities will just
keep coming back, keep coming back, keep coming back. and that's
why we need God to work, and that's why we need revival. So
let us learn to pray and to pray more for the future of our nation. And if you don't know the Lord
tonight, we're praying for you that you will come to know him as
your savior. Let us pray. Father in heaven, we pray concerning
this matter. We commit it to you. We pray
that you might be pleased to move in parliament so that this
bill will be defeated we leave it all in your hands we thank
you for the gift of life and help us to use this precious
gift for your glory and not to squander the time redeeming the
time because the days are evil for christ's sake amen we'll
just say
Christian Response to Euthanasia; Cruel or Compassionate
24/11/24
Full notes from this sermon can be accessed on our website
http://hopeinthevalley.co.uk/2024/11/24/assisted-dying-compassionate-or-cruel/
| Sermon ID | 1124242056455 |
| Duration | 43:01 |
| Date | |
| Category | Sunday Service |
| Bible Text | Ecclesiastes 3; Ecclesiastes 3:2 |
| Language | English |
© Copyright
2026 SermonAudio.